"This is the dumbest thing!" a student complained the other day while practicing reading weather station symbols. "I will never, ever use this in my real life," he scoffed in disgust, tossing his paper aside.
I couldn't contradict him; as fascinating as I personally found the exercise, I had made it to age 62 without knowing how to before.
In our state, the standardized middle school science test is given in eighth grade, and covers the curriculum from 6th, 7th, and 8th grades. I have listened sympathetically in the past as science teachers have complained about the inanity of that situation, and applauded their creativity in reviewing the material, even going so far as to have the sixth and seventh grade teachers teach the eighth grade classes for a day and review the units they had taught them in the years before. This year, there were some voluntary after-school review sessions for 8th graders, but I can't say how well they were attended.
When I told one of the other sixth-grade science teachers the story about the kid who was complaining so bitterly about the weather station, she laughed and said, "There is one place he's going to need it. They always have a question on weather stations on the SOL."
My eyes widened a bit, and the gravity of teaching the weather unit weighed a little bit more on me, especially knowing the students might not revisit the material again until they saw it on the test two years from now. So today, when I saw one of the eighth-grade students I know after school, my first question was, "How was the science SOL?"
"Fine," he shrugged. "Easy. I finished it pretty quickly."
"Was there a question on weather?" I asked.
"Maybe?" he said. "To be honest, I've already forgotten."