It took me a while to get there, but in the last decade or so of my teaching career, I chose not to make a big deal out of it when a student wasn't prepared with a pencil or other writing utensil. Instead, I simply ordered enough pencils to supply anyone who was without. Oh, it was still an expectation of the class for students to bring something to write with, but if they didn't, I was prepared.
Of course, it was galling to me initially, and a part of me was a little irritated right up until the end that whoever it was couldn't bother to come prepared for school, but I knew that wasn't always the case. In sixth grade, it's not necessarily an enormous character flaw to forget or even "forget" a pencil. Sometimes, it might have been a case of laziness, for sure, but most of the time, it was a function of disorganization, inattention, lack of means, or even the desire to stick it to the teacher.
In every one of those cases, it was better for me to give the kid a pencil and move on. I realized that my objective was not to investigate or scold someone for not having what they needed. My main purpose wasn't even to build character or responsibility, either; I was there to teach English, and if someone needed a pencil to help learn the lesson I planned, then bless their heart, they could have one, no questions asked.
I bring this up now because our community seems to be inundated by dog shit lately. I know, both because I've noticed myself and because, as a board member, Heidi has received several complaints. We have many dogs in the complex, and so we have trashcans and bags positioned throughout the neighborhood. One of these clean-up stations has been without bags for a couple weeks, and the conversation has focused on that a bit.
"I kind of feel that, as a dog owner, those bags are nice to have, not need to have," commented one board member. "Shouldn't all dog owners be prepared when they take their dog out?"
She's not wrong, but there has been poop spotted even in the vicinity of stations that are equipped with bags. "We should send out a strongly-worded message!" suggested another.
Heidi was still mad when we talked about it later. "I wish we could get cameras and fine people who don't pick up after their dogs!" she said.
"Maybe we should just hire somebody to clean it up," I said.
"The board will never go for that." She shook her head. "And why should we? People are supposed to pick up after their dogs!"
"I agree," I replied, "but is it your objective to teach people a lesson about good dog ownership by scolding and punishing them when we can catch them, or is it to get rid of the poop?" I knew she would get it-- Heidi has a huge supply of pencils her classroom.
So far, the rest of the board doesn't quite see it that way. That strongly-worded email is going out tomorrow.